How are Hawaiian Islands When Compared to The Caribbean?

traveller Budget Wayfarers

Confused between Hawaii versus Caribbean? Well, you’re not alone! Thousands of travellers are stuck choosing between these tropical paradises for their vacation. 

Hawaii and the Caribbean both offer exquisite beaches, water sporting activities, good food, plenty of exploring possibilities and more. But if you had to pick one, you need to evaluate their major differences. which is precisely what we do here.

Hawaii Versus Caribbean

Also Useful:

What to Choose Between Hawaii And Bahamas?

Hawaii Versus Caribbean: Choosing the Better Vacation Destination 

Let us begin by analyzing the major differences between the two islands – 


United States


Caribbean Sea





7-DAY TRIP COST (2 People)

2800-6000 USD


2000-5000 USD


Very Good 




Very Good








Traditional Hawaiian


Diverse & Fusion




Very Good


Budget-Friendly to Luxurious


Budget-Friendly to Luxurious


Very Good


Very Good






Very Good











Hawaii and Caribbean are separate regions located thousands of miles away. While Hawaii is a part of the US, Caribbean Islands are a group of Islands located southeast of Central America, and north of South America.

Let’s find out by comparing Hawaii and the Caribbean on the metrics in the table above and more, considering factors like Caribbean Citizenship by Investment opportunities for those interested in international real estate options or getting a second passport –

Comparing the Weather And Best Time to Visit Between Hawaii & Caribbean

Hawaii is stable throughout the year. You can experience a warm and sunny climate all year round making it perfect for a vacation.

The best time to visit Hawaii is between March to October.  During this time, Hawaii witnesses the least rain. However, to beat the crowds, you can also plan a trip between October and December. 

The Caribbean region has fluctuating weather, one reason for which is the sheer size of the islands covering around 30 nations. Most islands are warm and sunny throughout the year. 

The ideal time to plan your visit to Caribbeans is the winter months i.e December to February when you will get a chance to enjoy the cruises. Alternatively, if you are looking for the cheapest travel option and don’t mind the rains then choose May to August. You can even avail of special budget travel deals during these months. The hurricane season in the Caribbean lasts from June until November, and during these months prices are the lowest and crowds thinner.

VERDICT: Hawaii has more stable weather. But if you are wondering Is the Caribbean warmer than Hawaii, then the answer is Yes! 

Hawaii vs Puerto Rico Climate

Hawaii has a diverse landscape, which makes it appeaing to travellers with varying tastes.

Is Caribbean Cheaper than Hawaii for Travellers?

If you’re travelling to Hawaiin islands, the average cost ranges from 2800 to 6000 USD including flight booking, food, travel, sightseeing, and lodging in a 2-3 star hotel for a 1 bedroom vacation rental

 Most Affordable Places in Hawaii:

  • Oahu
  • Molokai
  • Big Island

The overall travel cost for a couple to the Caribbean island is about 2000-5000 USD for a week. Remember this is the average cost and may vary with the island/ country you are planning to visit. 

 Most Affordable Places in the Caribbean:

  • Trinidad & Tobago
  • Barbados
  • Turks & Caicos
  • Puerto Rico
  • Jamaica
  • Dominican Republic

VERDICT: The Caribbean is slightly cheaper than Hawaii based on the overall travel cost.

The Island Experience in Hawaii Versus the Caribbean

Hawaii comprises 8 major island islands – Hawai’i, Maui, Koho’olawe, Moloka’i, Lana’i, O’ahu, Kaua’i and Ni’ihau. One of the best parts about Hawaii is the landscape variation it offers.

In tiny Hawaii, you get to see the deserts, tropical rainforests, sprawling beaches and snow-peaked mountains. Travelling between these islands or island hopping is quite easy.

The Caribbean region consists of 700 islands divided into more than 20 sovereign states. Cuba and the Dominican Republic are the largest countries in the region.

Since the Caribbean is divided into separate countries, travelling between them will be an effort. Even travelling between the islands in the same country can turn out to be a hassle and expensive.

VERDICT: Although Hawaii is much smaller than the Caribbean, it offers a unique island experience with Island hopping made easier. 

Bahamas vs Hawaii Beaches

The Caribbean has some of the most beautiful and unique beaches like the Pig beach in Exumas, Bahamas.

Hawaii Vs Caribbean: The Battle of The Beaches

The magnificent Hawaiian islands consist of beautiful white, black, red and green sandy beaches.

Best beaches in Hawaii:

  • Punalu’u 
  • Keauhou 
  • Waikiki 
  • Ko Olina 
  • Kalapaki 
  • Kahaluu 

The Caribbean islands are known for their warm waters with the clearest water and shimmering white and pink sandy beaches. 

Best beaches in the Caribbean region:

  • Exuma, Bahamas
  • Shoal Bay, Anguilla
  • Brown, Barbados
  • Bavaro, Dominican Republic
  • Grace Bay, Turks and Caicos
  • Flamenco, Puerto Rico
  • Negril, Jamaica
  • Eagle Beach, Aruba

VERDICT:  If beaches are your main priority, The Caribbean is a better choice. 

Hawaii vs Puerto Rico Sightseeing

The Caribbean is know for its historic cities and cultural sites like  Castillo San Felipe del Morro in Puerto Rico

Hawaii or Caribbean, For the Explorer In You

Hawaii is well-known for volcanoes, beaches, museums, active volcanoes and national parks. As a explorer, there are plenty of things you can see in Hawaii.

Popular Places To Visit in Hawaii:

  • Haleakala National Park
  • Honolulu Museum of Art
  • Na-Pali Coast
  • Pearl Harbour
  • Waimea Canyon
  • Diamond Head
  • Waikiki Aquarium
  • Nahuku- Thurston Lava Tube
  • Spouting Horn

The Caribbean region is popular for its beautiful beaches, turquoise waters,a plethora of colonial cities, all-inclusive resorts and pleasant weather.  Depending on the place you are visiting, you will also find historic forts, plantations, volcanoes and more. 

Popular Places to Visit in The Caribbean:

  • San Juan, Puerto Rico
  • Blue Mountains, Jamaica
  • National Bridge Ruins,  Aruba
  • Havana, Cuba
  • Nassau, Bahamas
  • Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic
  • Virgin Gorda, British Virgin Islands
  • Brimstone Hill Fortress, St. Kitts

VERDICT: There are plenty of places to explore and visit in both Hawaii and the Caribbean

Hawaii Vs Bahamas Things to Do

Hawaii is not only about beaches. You can explore national parks, waterfalls and volcanoes all in the same state.

More Exciting Option for Adventurers: Hawaii or Caribbean?

Hawaii is a dream come true for thrill-seeking travellers. The islands will intrigue you with hiking, trekking, snorkelling, surfing, and other outdoor activities. It is the perfect spot for an active vacation.

Best activities in Hawaii:

  • Hawaii Tropical Botanical Garden
  • Helicopter Tour in Maui
  • Hiking in Kalalau Trail and Waikiki Island 
  • Waimea Canyon driving tour
  • Horseback Riding Tours
  • Witnessing eruptions at Volcano National Park
  • Snorkelling and Scuba
  • Mountain Tubing
  • Whale Watching

The Caribbean region has a laid-back vibe but it does offer a diverse platter of activities for travellers. However, since the region is quite large, unlike Hawaii one island or country may not offer all the experiences. So, make sure you first check what you want and then decide the destination.

Best activities in the Caribbean:

  • Hike Waitukubuli National trail, Dominica
  • Swimming with pigs, Bahamas
  • Swim with stingrays, Cayman Islands,
  • Whale watching, Dominican Republic
  • Dunns River Falls, Jamaica
  • Hike Gros Piton, St Lucia
  • Hike El Yunque Rainforest, Puerto Rico
  • Water Sports Activities

VERDICT: Hawaii is a better choice if you are looking for an array of activities. They offer better water sporting activities and other adventures all in one place

Food in Hawaii vs Bahamas

Seafood  lover will never be disappointed in the Caribbean.

Comparing the Unique Food Culture of Hawaii and the Caribbean

Hawaii is famous for its fresh tropical fruits that can be bought from local farmer’s markets. Apart from that “Plate Lunch” is something you must try when in Hawaii.

Local Food to Try in Hawaii:

  • Haupia
  • Loco Moco
  • Poi
  • Laulau
  • Poke Bowl
  • Manapua
  • Hawaiian Cocktails

The Caribbean region has numerous islands that are famous for their seafood cuisine, rum drinks, spice rubs, marinades and mouth-watering hot sauces. 

Local Food to Try in the Caribbean:

  • Martinican cuisines (like Lambis, Boudin, Accra), Martinique
  • Coucou and Flying fish, Barbados
  • Conch fritters, Bahama
  • Jerk Chicken and Rum Punch, Jamaica
  • Mofongo, Puerto Rico
  • La Bandera, Dominican Republic
  • Creole Bread, St. Lucia

VERDICT: Both Hawaii and the Caribbean specialize in their own kind of food.

What’s Better Hawaii or Caribbean for Experiencing An Amazing Nightlife?

Hawaii will give you a completely thrilling nightlife experience. The best clubs in Hawaii are located in Honolulu, Waikiki, and Chinatown. Apart from the clubs, there are many 

Best Nightlife Spots in Hawaii:

  • Rumtar
  • Zanzabar
  • Mai Tai 
  • Wang Chung
  • Honolulu city lights trolley tour 
  • Trolley tour
  • Fireworks at Hilton Hawaiian Village

The Caribbean, has some of the best islands for experiencing nightlife. With all night clubs, beach partes, 

Best Nightlife Spots in the Caribbean:

  • San Juan, Puerto Rico
  • Jost Van Dyke, British Virgin Islands
  • Negril, Jamaica
  • Punta Cana,  Dominican Republic
  • St. Barts
  • Barbados
  • Aruba
  • St. Lucia

VERDICT: Hawaii and Caribbean both have excellent Nightlife. Some of the islands in Caribbean are world-famous for their nightlife.

Accommodation Options & Costs in Hawaii Vs Caribbean

Hawaii offers a wide range of accommodation options for travellers. You can choose to stay in budget hotels, guesthouses, hostels and all-inclusive resorts with prices ranging from 75 USD to 500 USD per night. 

Average Price Per Person in Hawaii:

Hotels: 150 USD – 350 USD

Hostels: 30-40 USD

Guesthouse: 75 – 95 USD

Resort: 170 – 500 USD

The cost and options of staying Carribean vary with the island you are going. In the Caribbean the average cost of hotels, guesthouses and all-inclusive resorts ranges from 20 USD to 800 USD. 

Average Price Per Person in Hawaii:

Hotels: 50 USD – 500 USD

Hostels: 30-50 USD

Guesthouse: 20-120 USD

Resort: 100– 850 USD

VERDICT: The Caribbean offers more reasonable stays in comparison to Hawaii. 

Hawaii vs Bahamas Safety

Hawaii is quite easy to explore even if you are travelling on your own as a solo traveller. 

Comparing the Travel Friendliness & Culture of Hawaii & the Caribbean 

Hawaii is very travel-friendly for all kinds of travellers- families, friends or solo. Internal transport is easily available which makes it easy to get around.

People in Hawaii ar  heartwarming and truly embibe the “Aloha Spirit” embibing their Polynesian ancestory. The culture is a blend of eastern and western influences. This beautiful and unique culture can be withessed in the Laua Feasts,  Hula Dance performances, Polynesian Culture centre at Oahu, Hapa-Haole music, and Native Hawaiian Cuisine. 

In most Caribbean countries, experiences are dominated by resort experiences. As a traveller you are more likely to be limited to your resort offering all-inclusive trip with food, wine & dining options.

When it comes to hospitality, the people of the Caribbean region are bright and friendly. You will experience the diverse cultures, and languages like Dutch, French, Spanish in different Islands but English is the common language spoken by locals  making it easier for tourists to communicate and visit the islands.  Caribbean region is well-known for its food (African, European, Indian, and Chinese Food), Caribbean Rum, fascinating carnival festivals and more.

VERDICT: Both Hawaii and Carribean are travel friendly offer different travel experiences and cultures.

Hawaii or Caribbean: Better Destination if You Have Cleanliness Concerns

Hawaii is quite clean in most visited areas.  Some of the cleanest areas in Hawaii to visit are Honolulu and Kahului-Wailuku-Lahaina

Since the Caribbean is a large region, the cleanliness varies from island to island. Aruba is the cleanest  in the Caribbean region. Other clean islands include St. Vincent, The British Virgin Islands, Saint Lucia, Turks & Caicos, St. Barks, Barbados, Antigua.

VERDICT: Hawaii is comparatively cleaener than majority of the Caribbean islands.

Hawaii or The Caribbean: The Safer Destination

Hawaii is one of the safest places in the US but there is a concern about car theft and unattended items. Moreover, it is also a safe place for solo travellers.

Focus on general safety like you would do in any other place.

Carribean region is generally a safe destination for travellers. However, beware of leaving your valuables unattended at the beaches, hotels or rental cars as they are vulnerable to thefts in places like Jamaica and The Dominican Republic.  

The safest islands in Caribbean include St. Barts, Anguilla, The Virgin Islands, Martinique, Turks and Caicos, St. Lucia, The Cayman Islands.

VERDICT: Hawaii is safer for travellers than the Caribbean

Is Hawaii or Caribbean Good for A Memorable Family Vacation?

Hawaii is an excellent destination for planning a family vacation. It offers many kid-friendly and family friedly adventure activities.

You can enjoy some relaxing time by the beaches, go on hikes, enjoy cruises, go snorkeling or surfing, swim with sea turtles, try zip lining and more.

Caribbean too offers several options that are suited for families. Depending on the islands you plan to visit, you can enjoy kid-friendly resort experience, hikes, watersports, etc. among other things.

Barbados, The Bahamas, The Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, Dominica, and the Virgin Islands are the best Caribbean Islands for a family vacation.   

VERDICT: Hawaii is better for family vacation than the Caribbean dies to the range of activities being provided in a small place. 

Hawaii vs Bahamas for Honeymoon

The Caribbean Islands offer some of the best resort experiences for honeymoon couples 

Better for A Romantic Honeymoon- Hawaii or Caribbean Islands?

Hawaii is an amazing place for married couples to enjoy the sandy beaches, clear fresh waters, Aloha spirit, and enjoy beautiful resorts in Maui, Oahu, Lanai in Hawaii. 

Experience the romantic sunset cruise, go for deep-sea diving, Kayaking in the Wailua River, and a must-visit to Honolulu – one of the most popular cities for honeymoon couples. 

The Caribbean region comprises the most romantic islands for honeymooners. You can spend some quality time  with your loved ones at the beaches and resorts.

Sone of the best romantic spots for newly-weds are  St. Lucia’s stunning beaches, Green Turtle Cay at the Bahamas, Anguilla, Aruba, Grand Turk, Turks and Caicos Islands.

VERDICT: Hawaii is a better option if you are looking for an adventurous honeymoon. Caribbean is suited for couples who want to relax.

Hawaii Vs Caribbean Islands: Taking The Last Call

So, overall both Hawaii and Caribbean are wonderful travel destinations worth visiting, Choose the one that matches most with your style of holidaying.

Before we end the blog, let’s answer a very popular question – Which Caribbean Island is Most like Hawaii? Saint Lucia is quite similar to Hawaii.

However, there are more islands that have similar beautiful beaches, majestic waterfalls, and amazing volcanoes. These include Turks & Caicos, Jamaica, Barbados, Grenada, Antigua, and the Bahamas.

Happy Wayfaring!


Budget Wayfarers

Budget Wayfarers is an online content platform for travelers and bloggers across the globe. It is a community for explorers, trippers, sightseers and nomads who want to discover the beauty that the world has to offer. Once on board, work for us from anywhere in the world. Blog for us from a country abroad, a coffee shop, a beach, a trek – just anywhere. Become a legit Travel Blogger on our platform. Document your travel stories and experiences of far and wide places. Get paid per contribution.